South Asian Research Publishing Organization (SARPO)

INTRODUCTION

The African pear tree (Dacryodes edulis (G.Don) H.J.Lam; Burseraceae) is a tropical oleiferous fruit tree that possesses enormous potential in Africa (Kengué, 1990). It is a non timber forest product (NTFP) that has in

many areas made a transition from the forest to the farm and it is commonly cultivated in agroforestry systems as a shade provider and secondary crop in cocoa and coffee farms (Okafor et al., 2002). The fruits are edible, and the bark; leaves, stems, and roots are employed for a variety of purposes (Waruhiu et al. 2004).

The fruit pulp may be cooked (softened) or eaten raw. The cooked flesh of the fruit has a texture similar to butter (Enujiugha, and Ayodele, 2005). Dacryodes edulis is a delicacy among the people of Nigeria where it is consumed as an accompaniment with fresh maize (Onuegbu, 2000; Agbogidi and Eshenbeyi, 2006), while the fruits are sold in local markets and, to some level, have attracted international trade (Ajibesin, 2011).

The scientific researches on Dacryodes edulis on the nutritive value of its pulp and its oil (Ajayi et al., 2006), and the oil extraction processes (Kapseu, 2009) have revealed excellent nutritional qualities of fruit pulp and interesting food processing properties of the oils extracted from the pulp and kernel of Dacryodes edulis (Poligui et al., 2013). The pulp, the only edible part of the fruit is particularly rich in lipids, indicating that D. edulis could be an important source of oil (Ondo-Azi et al., 2013).

Besides lipids, the pulp contains substantial amounts of many other nutrients including proteins, carbohydrates, minerals, vitamins, and fibers (Poligui et al., 2013).

The wood of Dacryodes edulis has general use for carpentry, tool handles, and occasionally for construction, the stem exudates serve as glue and cosmetic components while the plant improves soil quality and contributes greatly to traditional medicines (Ajibesin, 2011).

The gathering of the fruits of Dacryodes edulis serves as a veritable source of employment and income for the rural populace (Agbogidi and Eshegbeyi, 2006). Dacryodes edulis fruits like most fruits are highly perishable due to the ease of spoilage by microorganisms resulting in a short shelf-life of about 3-5 days (Onuorah et al., 2001).

This has led to huge losses and market gluts during harvest as noticed by large heaps of unsold rotten fruits in the refuge dumps or sites of villages and urban markets when the supply of a good or service far exceeds its demand, usually resulting in a substantial fall in its price in the market (Nwanekezi, 2007). This problem of perishability has an effect on the marketing efficiency of the fruit because marketers are often compelled to sell their fruits at a very low price to avoid huge wastage or total loss (Awono et al., 2002).

The Marketing of Non-Timber Forest Products (NTFPs) is reported to be characterized by an inefficient marketing system. The problems of poor marketing facilities, transportation costs, seasonality of products, crude storage and processing, supply and demand constraints, consumer preferences, and inefficient pricing systems have characterized the trade (Awono et al., (2002); Busari Ahmed et al., (2015); Fon Dorothy and Mbondji Ntombe (2018); Meinhold and Darr (2019). An efficient marketing system is vital to sustain profitability and promote the provision of jobs and income thus drastically reduce poverty.

According to Pandey et al., (2016) and Nzeh et al., (2015), the market of NTFP is extremely imperfect and unstructured with complex value chains and multiple stages and actors involved in the process of getting a product from forest to consumer. They are also dynamic and change over time and as such information about the quantity and quality of the product, price, and market are very important.

With increasing population pressure, the upsurge of demand and commercial value for this multipurpose forest fruit tree species, as well as the seasonality of fruit production and the inability of the fruits to store well for a long period of time (Onuegbu, 2000, Shackleton and Pandey, 2014), it is important to study the socioeconomic benefits derivable from the tree species.

According to Ingram and Bongers (2009) the contribution of NTFPs to the subsistence economy and to food security, to the national economy as a source of employment and for trade and exports, is missing in forestry and economic statistics. The paucity of information on NTFPs is reflected in the lack of policy attention, conflicting regulatory and policy frameworks, and a lack of support for the trade-in of these products (Tahir et al., 2004; Belcher, 2005; Ingram and Bongers, 2009).

Therefore, adequate knowledge and information regarding the capacity of Dacryodes edulis to contribute significantly to the improvement of the economic status local population and providing a safety net can be important for food security. This study specifically identified the various uses and marketing channels of Dacryodes edulis, determined the market structure and performance and income accrued in the marketing of Dacryodes edulis, and identified the challenges of its marketing system Makurdi Local Government Area.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Study area

The study was carried out in Makurdi Local Government Area, one of the twenty-three Local Government Areas in the Benue State of Nigeria. Makurdi Local Government Area is the headquarters of Benue State, Nigeria. It lies between longitude 8° and 9° East and between latitude 7° and 8° North in the middle belt region of Nigeria. The climate of Makurdi town is the tropical wet and dry type, Koppen’s Aw classification, with double maxima (Ayoade, 1983).

The rainy season lasts from April to October, with 5 months of the dry season (November to March). Annual rainfall in Makurdi town is consistently high, with an average annual total of approximately 1173 mm (Abah, 2012). The temperature in Makurdi is, however, generally high throughout the year, with February and March as the hottest months.

The temperature in Makurdi varies from a daily of 40 °C and a maximum of 22.5 °C (Ologunorisa and Tor, 2006). The vegetation of Makurdi town is the guinea savannah type. This vegetation type has been adversely affected by human activities leading to the clear-cutting of tree cover in many parts of the town. Due to this, artificial vegetation has replaced natural secondary vegetation. Makurdi town is inhabited by many tribes

with a population of 297,398 to 157,295 males and 140,103 females (FGN, 2007). These tribes include the Tivs, Idomas, Etilos, Jukuns, Egede, Hausas, Yorubas, and Ibos. The Tivs are the dominant tribe. Makurdi town is made up largely of people who engage in civil service duties, commercial activities, and agrarian peasantry. Makurdi town is a built-up area with the highest concentration of people in high level and Wadata. A dense population also exists in some low-lying parts of the town such as Wurukum.

Population and sampling procedure

The population is comprised of marketers of Dacryodes edulis within Makurdi Metropolis. The study was carried out in three markets purposively selected based on the availability of Dacryodes edulis in such markets. The purposively selected markets were; Wurukum Market, Wadata Market, and Modern Market respectively. Thus, 57 marketers from Wurukum Market, 53 marketers from Wadata Market, and 33 marketers from Modern Market were sampled making a total of 143 marketers using the Taro-Yamane formula. The formula is shown below:

n =^��

1+��(��)₂

Where:

n=corrected sampled size,

N= population size,

e = marginal of error (10%)

Data collection

Data for this research project were collected through oral interviews and the administration of a semi-structured questionnaire. An oral interview was conducted with selected marketers of Dacryodes edulis in each of the three markets selected. A structured questionnaire was administered to one hundred and forty-three (143) marketers of Dacryodes edulis in the three selected markets. It was administered to fifty-seven respondents in the Wurukum market, fifty-three respondents in the Wadata market, and thirty-three respondents in Modern market areas of Makurdi Local Government Area of Benue State.

Data analysis

The data collected was analyzed using descriptive statistics such as frequency, percentages and mean, and tables. SPSS Statistics Version 20 was used to analyze the data. The Gross Margin analysis was applied to determine the profitability of Dacryodes edulis marketing. The Gini – coefficient was used to determine the total quantity of Dacryodes edulis sold in the markets.

Determination of gross margin

The gross margin is determined mathematically using the formula:

GM = GI – TVC

Where:

GM = Gross Margin

GI = Gross Income

TVC = Total Variable Cost

Determination of market concentration

Gini – Coefficient is determined by the formula:

G = 1 – ∑XY ………………………………………………. 1 Where:

G = Gini-coefficient

X = Cumulative percentage of sellers Y = Cumulative percentage of sales

NOTE: G has a value ranging from 0-1 expressing the extent to which the market is concentrated. When G = 0, there is perfect equality in the size of the distribution of sellers, but when G = 1, there is inequality in the size of sellers.

RESULTS

Socio-economic characteristics of respondents in the study area

The result revealed that the majority of the marketers (80.4%) were female and only 19.6% were male. Most respondents in the study area were between 41-50 years (50%), only 7% were less than 20 years, 16% were between 21-30 years, 27% were between 31- 40 years and 14% were less than 50 years (Table 1). In terms of marital status as a greater proportion (68.5%) of the result were married while 31.3% were single.

In terms of educational level, the majority of the respondents (37.8%) of the respondents had informal education, this is by followed primary education (32.9%), secondary education (26.6%) while only 2.8% had tertiary education. Based on years of experience of the respondents, a greater proportion of the respondents (32.9%) had between 5-10 years of experience in Dacryodes edulis marketing, 31.5% had 10-15 years of experience, 16.1% had less than 5, 12.6% had 15-20 years, while 7.0% had marketing experience greater than 20 years.

Various uses of Dacryodes edulisFrom Table 2 it is revealed that a higher proportion (72.7%) use it for food, 23.78% use it for medicine while only 3.5% indicated that they use it for oil extraction.

Table 1. Socio-economic characteristics of respondents.

Table 2. Various uses of Dacryodes edulis

Variables Frequency Percentage (%) Food (fruit) 104 72.7

Medicine (leaves and bark) 34 23.78

Oil extraction (seed) 5 3.5

Total 143 100

Membership of the market association

The result from Table 3 indicated that the majority (61.5%) of the traders do not belong to the association while only 38.5% are members of the association.

Table 3. Respondents’ membership in the association

Membership in Association Frequency Percentage (%) Yes 55 38.5 No 88 61.5 Total 143 100.0

Nature of business

Table 4 shows that 51.0% of the marketers of Dacryodes edulis are involved in a retail business, 30.8% are involved in Wholesale while only 18.2% are into both wholesale and retail business.

Table 4. Nature of business of Dacryodes edulis marketers in Makurdi LG Nature of Business Frequency Percentage Retail 73 51.0

Wholesale 44 30.8

Wholesale and Retail 20 18.2

Sales and supply period

The highest period (62.2%) of Dacryodes edulis supply is obtained between January and March followed by April to June (26.6%) while the least supply period (11.2%) is from July to September (Table 5).

Table 5. Sales and supply period of Dacryodes edulis

Variables Frequency Percentage (%) Period supplied most

Jan – March 80 55.9 April – June 59 41.3 July – Sept 4 2.8 Total 143 100.0 Period sold most

Jan – March 89 62.2 April – June 38 26.6 July – Sept 16 11.2 Total 143 100.0

Market concentration in Dacryodes edulis marketing in Makurdi LGA

Table 6 shows the result of the market concentration of Dacryodes edulis in the study area. The result indicates that the highest proportion of sellers 30.1% accounted for 30.1% of sales, this was followed by 25.9% sellers of accounting for 27.4% of sales, 23% of sellers accounted for 21.4% of sales while the least proportion of sellers (5.6%) possessed 7.3% of sales at the market weekly.

Table 6. Gini-coefficient analysis of Dacryodes edulis sales in Makurdi LGA

Sales Freque ncy

Percen tage of Sellers X

Cumulat ive % of Sellers

Total Sales

Percentag e of Sales

Cumulative % of Sales

Y

XY

200001.00- 400000.00 400001.00- 600000.00 600001.00- 800000.00 800001.00- 1000000.00

1000001.00 +

37 25.9 25.9 999000 27.4 27.4 0.0709 43 30.1 55.9 1100000 30.1 57.5 0.1715 22 15.4 71.3 503500 13.8 71.3 0.1090 33 23.1 94.4 783000 21.4 92.7 0.2141 8 5.6 100.0 265000 7.3 100.0 0.0560

Total 100.0 100.0 3650500 100.0 0.6223

GC = 1 – ∑XY = 1 – 0.6223 = 0.3777

Marketing channels of Dacryodes edulis in Makurdi LGA

As shown in Table 7, the majority of the respondents (38.5%) indicated that the channel used in the acquisition of the fruit is through farm gate middlemen, 30.1% of the respondents indicated that they get the product through wholesales, 21.7% indicated that they obtain Dacryodes edulis directly from the farmers while only 9.8% of the respondents indicated that they get their product from neighboring states.

Table 7. Marketing channels of Dacryodes edulis marketing in Makurdi LGA

Variables Frequency Percentage (%) Farmers 31 21.7 Farmgate middlemen 55 38.5 Wholesalers 43 30.1 Neighboring state 14 9.8 Total 143 100.0 Source: Field Survey, (2019)

Profitability of Dacryodes edulis marketing

At the end of each week, traders in Wurukum Market go home with N 29, 842.11; similarly, the traders in Modern Market go home with N 29,727.27 while those of Wadata Market go home with N 27,830.19 (Table 8).

Table 8. Weekly profitability of Dacryodes edulis marketing in Makurdi LGA

Markets A

No. of Traders B

C.P

(100kg) C

(N)

S.P

(100kg) D

(N)

WQS E

WVC

F

(N)

Total C.P

G (C x E) (N)

Total S.P

H (D x E) (N)

TVC

I (F + G) (N)

GM

J (H – I)

(N)

GM/Trad er

K(J/B)

(N)

_{Wurukum 57 23,500 26,500 570 9000} 13,395,0 00

15,105,00 0

13,404,0 00

1,701 ,000

29,842.1 1

_{Modern 33 24,000 27,000 330 9000 7,920,00 8,910,000} 7,929,00 0

981,0 00

29,727.2 7

_{Wadata 53 24,000 26,800 530 9000} 12,720,0 00

14,204,00 0

12,729,0 00

1,475 ,000

27,830.1 9

NOTE: C.P = Cost Price, S.P = Selling Price, WQS = Weekly Quantity Sold, WVC = Weekly Variable Cost (Government Collection 5000 + Transportation 4000 = 9000), TVC = Total Variable Cost, GM = Gross Margin

T-Test analysis of gross margin of Dacryodes edulis marketing

Tables 9 and 10 show the T-Test analysis of Dacryodes edulis marketing in Makurdi Metropolis. The analysis indicated that the overall gross margin was significant but with no significant differences in the profit generated across the 3 markets.

Table 9. T-Test Analysis of Gross margin Dacryodes edulis marketing in Makurdi LGA

T Df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean Difference 95% Confidence Interval of the Difference

Lower Upper

GM 23.656 142 0.000* 38758.74126 35519.8782 41997.6043 *Significant at 5% level of probability

Table 10. T-Test for the three markets of Dacryodes edulis marketing sampled in Makurdi LGA

Market T Df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean Difference 95% Confidence Interval of the

Difference

Lower

Wurukum Market GM 14.416 56 0.000* 40163.15789 34582.2712 Modern Market GM 10.451 32 0.000* 40284.84848 32433.0559 Wadata Market GM 16.379 52 0.000* 36298.11321 31851.1963

Challenges in the marketing of Dacryodes edulis

Table 11 the lack of storage facilities (23.1%) is the major constraint facing the marketing of Dacryodes edulis. This was followed by Transportation (21.7%), lack of capital (21.0%), seasonal fluctuations (9.1%), high cost of tax (7%), and sources of supply (14.0%) while the least challenge indicated was government policies (4.2).

Table 11. Challenges in Dacryodes edulis marketing

Variables Frequency Percentage (%) Lack of storage facilities 33 23.1 Transportation 31 21.7 Lack of capital 30 21.0 Supply sources 20 14.0 Market price instability 13 9.1 Tax 10 7.0 Government policies 6 4.2 Total 143 100.0 Source: Field Survey, (2019)

DISCUSSION

The predominance of the female gender in the marketing of Dadryodes edulis could be because retailing requires a certain level of patience and it takes one or more days to finish the stock and also that most urban retailers are mostly women with stalls in the market or roadside sellers Nzeh et al. (2018).

Awono et al. (2002). According to Velde (2006), the dominance of women reason is that it requires few capital inputs for trading and also it tends to have low returns per unit and such reasonable incomes can usually only be achieved based on high volumes traded, for which capital to buy, store and transport products is needed.

The majority of the respondents being above 21 years of age implies that those most engaged in the marketing of Dacryodes edulis were adults and their involvement in the trade sustains their livelihood.

This finding is in line with the submission of Okumadewa et al. (2000) that traders in this age group are productive and energetic with greater potential for better performance and to explore opportunities in their existing trade business. The greater number of respondents being married implies that Dacryodes edulis marketing serves as a source of income to marketers as marriage confers responsibility and thus helps them cater to their family needs (Akinbile, 2007).

The fact that the majority of the respondents have formal education defines their effectiveness towards their livelihood activities. Based on the years of experience of the respondents, a greater proportion of the respondents have long years of experience in the trade of Dacryodes edulis which means that most traders are involved in the marketing of Dacryodes edulis have been in the business for long and are quite experienced in the trade.

The use Dacryodes edulis mostly for food according to Onuegbu and Ihebiohanma (2008) is due to the important role it plays in the nutrition of the people. Dimelu and Odo (2013); Omonihinmin (2014); and Kadji et al. (2016) also reported that Dacryodes edulis is used for many purposes such as medicine, food, fed to livestock, vegetable oil, and fruit pulp.

The fact that the majority of the marketers are members of market associations implies that access to the market must be granted by the officials. The individual intending to become a trader follows a procedure by meeting with the officials to seek recognition as a member of the market.

The dominance of retailers in the trade can be explained by the fact that women are involved more in retailing generally because the work is usually within their area of residence while men are more concentrated in the wholesale trade (Awono et al., 2002, Fon Dorothy and Mbondji Ntombe 2018). Wholesalers buy products directly from producers in rural areas to resell in the wholesale markets in urban areas either directly to retailers or to sedentary wholesalers who are sometimes between wholesalers and retailers. The same people could play the role of wholesalers and retailers.

The reason most of the traders indicated that that supply is mostly between January to March implies that the supply and the selling period are within the same period and this is because Dacryodes edulis is a seasonal fruit and cannot be stored for a long time to sell it at a convenient time. The is in line with the finding of Agbonkolo et al. (2016).

The Gini-correlation of Dacryodes edulis marketing obtained in the study area was 0.3777. According to Tedro (1981) for relatively equitable distribution, the Gini coefficient value should be between 0.20 and 0.35. UNDP reported that Gini-coefficient with high inequality typically lies between 0.5 and 0.7. This implies that Dacryodes edulis marketers were not able to control large proportions of supply or sales in the study area. As such, none could influence supplies by increasing or decreasing the quantity supplied.

There is no formal setting to guide the determination of the price of Dacryodes edulis which means individual marketers can sell their products at the price they feel is fit provided the buyers agree to buy at that rate. Therefore, the marketing of Dacryodes edulis is determined and controlled by the forces of demand and supply. The high perishability of the fruit also makes it difficult to place a fixed price on the product.

Each of the participant outputs was an insignificant part of the volume of trade in the market such that it could not affect market price. The overall structure of D. edulis market indicates that there are many small-scale traders such that

none could control the market. The individual dealers have little influence on the market price. Sambe (2015) and Enete (2008) made a similar observation with Timber Trade Analysis in Benue State, Nigeria, and Charcoal in Abia State, Nigeria.

There are mainly four marketing channels of Dacryides edulis in the study area. A farmer may sell his produce through farm gate meddle men for further distribution to wholesalers or sale directly to wholesalers. Dacrydes edulis can also be gotten from neighboring states like Enugu but this happens in rare cases. Mostly, Dacryodes edulis is obtained from Vandeikya and Kwande Local Government Areas of Benue State which presently stand as the dominant producers of the fruit in the State. The distribution channel from forest collector to urban wholesaler consists of middlemen that sell it to local traders which in turn sell it to the urban center and finally reach consumers.

The amount generated per trader in each of the markets suggests that the business is profitable since it is higher than the minimum wage presently in Nigeria. Agbokolor et al. (2016) reported a positive marketing efficiency greater than one in Imo State Nigeria while Ibeagwa et al. (2020) reported a profitability index of 0.43 (43%) and a Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR) of 2.31 of NTFPs which all indicate moderate profitability and viability in Edo State respectively.

He posited that this could be due to fluctuations in supply due to the seasonality of the products as well their high perishability and also because the demand for agricultural produce including NTFPs in many developing countries is inelastic and this affects the price and ultimately profitability.

This implies that lack of storage facilities, poor and high transportation network, and cost and lack of capital are the major problems in the marketing of the products. This finding is in line with that of Ndubueze et al. (2018) that poor transportation network and perishability are the basic challenges in seasonal fruit marketing.

REFERENCES

Ajibesin, K. K. Dacryodes edulis (G. Don) H. J. Lam: A review on its medicinal, phytochemical and economic properties. Research Journal of Medicinal Plant. 2011, 5(1), 32- 41.

Atangana, A. R.; Asaah, E.; Tchoundjeu, Z.; Schreckenberg, K.; Leakey, R. R. B. Biophysical characterization of Dacryodes edulisfruits in three markets in Cameroon. 2002, 106–118 pp.

Awono, A. O.; Ndoye, K.; Schreckenberg, H.; Tabuna, F. I.; Temple, L. Production and marketing of Safou (Dacryodes edulis) in Cameroon and internationally. Market development issues. Forest, Trees and Livelihoods, 2002, (12), 125-147.

Ayoola, P. B.; Adeyeye, A.; Onawumi, O. O.; Faboya, O, O. P. Phytochemical and Nutrient Evaluation of Tetracarpidium conophorum (African Walnut) Root. International Journal of Research and Reviews in Applied Sciences, 2011, 7(2),197- 202.

Ayuk, E. T.; Duguma, B.; Franzel, S.; Kengue, J.; Mollet, M.; Tiki-Manga, T.; Zekeng, P. Uses, management and economic potentials of Dacryodes edulis (Burseraceae) in the humid lowlands of Cameroon. Economic Botany. 1999, 53(3), 292-301.

Bakari, U. M.; Usman, J. Marketing of some selected vegetables in Yola-north and south local government areas of Adamawa State, Nigeria. International Journal of Engineering and Science 2013, 2(11), 2319-1805.

Belcher, B. M. Forest product markets, forests, and poverty reduction. International Forestry Review. 2005, 7(2), 82-89.

Busari, Ahmed; idris-Adeniyi, K. M.; Lawal A. O. Food Security and Post-Harvest Losses in Fruit Marketing in Lagos Metropolis,

Nigeria. Discourse Journal of Agriculture and Food Sciences. 2015, 3(3), 52-58. Dabonne, S. Physico-chemical properties of Safou (Dacryodes edulis) fruits grown in Côte d’Ivoire. Journal of Applied Biosciences. 2016, 105, 10103 –10110. Dimelu, M. U.; Odo, R. N. Production preference and importance of fruit species in home garden among rural households in Igbo-Eze North Agricultural Zone of Enugu State, Nigeria. Afr. J. Agric. Res. 2013, 8(46), 5733-5740.

Enete, A. A. Resource use, marketing and diversification decision in Cassava producing households of Sub-Saharan Africa. Ph.D. Thesis Dissertation, K.U. Leuven. 2003.

Enujiugha, V. N.; Ayodele, O. Evaluation of Nutrients and anti-nutrients in lesser known under-utilized oil seeds. International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 2005, 38 (1), 525-528.

Eze, S. O.; Onwubuya E. A.; Ezeh, A. N. Women marker’s perceived constraints on selected Agricultural Produce marketing in Enugu South Area: Challenges of Extension Training for Women Groups in Enugu State, Nigeria. Agro-science Journal of Tropical, Agricultural, Food, Environment and Extension. 2010, 9(3), 215- 222.

For Dorothy, E.; Mbondji Ntombe, P. B.; Analysis of marketing channels of Plum (Dacryodes edulis) from the Njombe-Penja production basin. Journal of Agricultural Science and Food Technology. 2018, 4 (9),173-181.

Ibeagwa, O. B.; Ehirim, N. C.; Ukoha, I. I.; Osuji, E. E.; Essien, U. A.; Offor, E. I.; Uhuegbulem, I. J.; Nnamerenwa, G. C. Analysis of the profitability and viability of the non-timber forest products marketing in Imo State, Nigeria, Kobia International Journal of Agriculture and Environmental Studies. 2020 1(1), 80-86.

Ingram, V.; Bongers, G. 2009. Valuation of non-timber forest product chains in the Congo basin: a methodology for valuation. CIFOR. Yaounde, Cameroon, FAO-CIFOR SNV-World Agroforestry Center COMIFAC. 80 p.

Kalenda D. T.; Ella Missang C.; Kinkela T.; Krebs H. C.; Renard, C. M. G. C.; New developments in the chemical characterization of the fruit of Dacryodes edulis (G. Don) H. J. Lam. Forests, Trees and Livelihoods. 2002, 12(12), 119–123.

Kar, P. S. Non-timber forest product (NTFP) utilization and livelihood development in Bangladesh. Ph. D. Dissertation. School of forest resources. Pennsylvania University, USA. 2010.

Kengue, J.; Kapseu, C.; Kayem G. J. (eds.) 3ème séminaire international sur la valorisation du Safoutier et autres oléagineux non-conventionnels Yaoundé, Cameroun, 3–5 October 2000. Presses Universitaires d’Afrique, Yaounde.

Kengue, J. C. African pear, Dacryodes edulis (G. Don) H. J. Lam. Journal on the Science of Food and Agriculture. 1990, (38), 67–72.

Kinkéla, T. R.; Kama-Niamayoua, D.; Mampouya, T. Variations in morphological characteristics, lipid content and chemical composition of safou (Dacryodes edulis (G. Don) J. Lam. According to fruit distribution: A case study. African Journal of Biotechnology. 2006, 5(12),1233- 1238.

Leakey, R. R. B.; Atangana, A. R.; Kengni E.; Waruhiu, A. N.; Usuro, C.; Anegbeh, P. O. Tchoundjeu Z. Domestication of Dacryodes edulis in West and Central Africa: Characterization of genetic variation. Forests, Trees, and Livelihoods. 2002, 12(1/2), 57–71.

Marlene Ngansop T.; Denis, J. Sonwac, Evariste Fongnzossie F.bd, Biyé Elvire H. b, Forbi Preasious F. ab, Takanori Oishie, and Nkogmeneck Bernard-Aloys. Identification of main Non-Timber Forest Products and related stakeholders in its value chain in the Gribe village of southeastern Cameroon. Conference paper march 2019.

Mbofung, C. M. F.; Silou, T.; Mouragadia, I. Chemical characterization of safou (Dacryodes edulis) and evaluation of its potential as an ingredient in nutritious biscuits. Forests Trees and Livelihoods. 2002, 12, 105 – 107.

Meinhold, K.; Darr, D. The processing of non timber forest products through small and medium enterprises – a review of enabling and constraining factors. Forests 2019, 10, 1026.

Nwaru, J. C.; Iwuji, O. Marketing margins and their determinants in plantain marketing in Owerri agricultural zone of Imo State, Nigeria; Agricultural Rebirth for Improved Production in Nigeria. In: Orherliata, A. M; Nwokoro, S. O.; Ajayi, M. T.; Adekunle, A. T.; Asumugha, G. N. (eds); Proceedings of the 39th Annual Conference of the Agricultural Society of Nigeria. University of Benin, Benin City. Oct 9, 2005, 13, 385-387.

Nzeh, E. C.; Eboh Chukwu, B.; Nzeh, L. Microeconomic analysis of marketing Non Timber Products (NTFPs) in Agwu Agricultural Zone of Enugu State, Nigeria. Asian Journal of Agriculture Extension, Economics and Sociology. 2018, 26(3), 1-9.

Nzeh, E. C.; Eboh, E.; Nweze, N. J. Status and trends of deforestation: An insight and lessons from Enugu State, Nigeria. Net Journal of Agricultural Science. 2015, 3(1), 23-31. Available: http://www.netjournals.org/pdf/NJAS/201

5/1/15-011.pdf ISSN: 2315-9766.

Oghogho, I. A.; Nwiwe, C. N.; Okere, R. A.; Oyaide, W. J. Marketing of perishable agricultural products in Benin City. a case study of Tomatoes, Bananas, and Pineapples. International Journal of Agricultural Economics and Rural Development. 2014, 6(1),102-109.

Omogbai, B. A.; Ojeaburu, S. I. Nutritional composition and microbial spoilage of Dacryodes edulis fruits vended in Southern Nigeria. Science World Journal 5(4), 5-10.

Omonhinmin, C. A. Ethnobotany of Dacryodes edulis (G.Don) H.J. Lam in Southern Nigeria 2. Practices and Application Among Igbo-speaking People. Journal Plants People and applied Sciences, Ethnobotany Research & Applications. 2014, 12, 71-80.

Pandey, A. K.; Tripathi, Y. C.; Kumar, A. Non timber forest Products (NTFPs) for sustained livelihood. Challenges and strategies. Res. J. For. 2010, 10,1-7.

Sambe, L. N. Analysis of timber trade in Benue State Msc unpublished thesis in the Department of Social and Environmental Forestry, Federal University of Agriculture, Makurdi. 2015.

Sofowora, L. A. Medicinal plants and traditional medicine in Africa. 2^nd Edition. Spectrum Book Ltd., Ibadan, Nigeria. 2008.

Tahir, B. A. E.; Gebauer, J. Non-timber forest products: opportunities and constraints for poverty reduction in the Nuba Mountains, South Kordofan, Sudan. Deutscher Tropentag Conference on International Agricultural Research for Development. Berlin, Deutschland. 2004.

Tchotsoua, M.; Mapongmetsem, P. M. Le safoutier (Dacryodes edulis): Zones ecologiques et commercialisation des fruits au Cameroon. 1998, Pp 261–272 in Kapseu C. and Kayem G.J. (eds.) 1998. Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on African pear improvement and other new sources of vegetable oils. ENSAI, Presses Universitaires de Yaoundé.

Te Velde, D. W. T.; Rushton, J.; Schreckenberg, K.; Marshall, E.; Edouard, F.; Newton, A.; Arancibia, E. Entrepreneurship in value chains of non timber forest products. Forest Policy and Economics. 2006, 8, 725- 741.

Waruhiu, A. N.; Kengue, J.; Tanana, A. R.; Tchound-jeu, Z.; Leakey, R. R. B. Domestication of Dacryodes edulis: 2. Phenotypic variation of fruit traits in 200 trees from four populations in the humid lowlands of Cameroon. Journal of Food, Agriculture and Environment. 2004, 2(1), 340- 346.